Responsive image
Article Rule of Law, or the Dilemma of an Ethos: to be Gardened or Mechanicised
Authors Varga Cs.
Name of magazine Scientific journal «Philosophy of Law and General Theory of Law» (Ukrainian language)
Issue 1 / 2013
Pages 48 - 64
Annotation

Post-dictatorship models for transition can be either total defeat with military control, breaking past continuity through preventing local practices to reorganise while re-educating for democracy (as in post-WWII) or just declaring full-pledged rule of law operating from now on (as in post-Communism). Practice may vary in whether or not the Rule of Law is a set of expectations categorically absolute and exhaustively codified or just a respectable ideal having once developed in response to particular challenges somewhere and somewhen, under given historical conditions. Then, it is an art of balancing amongst conflicting values within its ethos: a strive never to end and close, as it is a learning process surfacing new features once new challenges are to be met. Eventually, a choice has to be made between attitudes characteristic of a circus trainer and a gardener. The temptation at substituting past nihilism to a kind of fetishism is also to be faced, as it may strengthen the dependence of target countries on pattern- following by weakening their self-responsibility, vitally needed for successful recovery.

Keywords post-dictatorship models for transition, Rule of Law, ethos, constitutional adjudication.
References
Electronic version Download