Article | Value-Related Challenges of Administrative Procedure Legislation |
---|---|
Authors | VITALII VDOVICHEN , TETIANA PODOROZHNA |
Name of magazine | Legal journal «Law of Ukraine» (Ukrainian version) |
Issue | 5 / 2019 |
Pages | 63 - 79 |
Annotation | The article focuses on the adoption of the codified act on administrative procedures as a new stage in the development of procedural legislation which establishes certain legal orders for resolution of administrative disputes (cases arising from administrative and other public relations). It is noted that, unfortunately, in this area of administrative legal relations there is an “unrealized potential” of the Constitution of Ukraine in terms of creating an administrative procedure form for the exercise of public administration. This is confirmed, in particular, by the gaps in the system of administrativelaw regulation of relations pertaining to the adoption of administrative acts; contradictions in the process of improving administrative procedure legislation; and finally, the backlog in the development of administrative-law theory of the approaches formed in the European countries, as well as principles and priorities of research in the area of juridification of public administration and legal arrangement of the interaction of administrative bodies and citizens with the aim of ensuring their rights and legitimate interests. And all this at the time when the need to satisfy the rights and legitimate interests of individuals during interaction with public authorities provides for clearly defined principles and rules which form the administrative procedure. The purpose of the article is to analyze – with due regard for legislative and practical aspects – the approaches which exist in the administrative law doctrine and are applied to the adoption of the administrative procedure code as the basic regulatory legal act intended to regulate the provision of administrative services by executive authorities and local self-government bodies. The author comes to the conclusion that the adoption of the administrative procedure code makes possible the following: to establish the proper procedure for implementation of administrative actions within one of the most important legal forms of public administration; to form the basis for efficient assurance of the rights, freedoms and legitimate interests of citizens and organizations interacting with public power and its bodies; to impart proper systematicity and robust structure to administrative-law regulation of administrative relations; not only to harmonize the internal structure of the administrative-law regulation mechanism, but also to create the basis for efficient court protection in administrative cases, i.e., to ensure fair and legitimate resolution of administrative and other public disputes; to resolve the tasks of administrative court proceedings set by the Code of Administrative Proceedings of Ukraine (CAP of Ukraine) at all stages forming this type of exercise of judicial power. The operation of this Code will ensure a further development of the administrative procedure form, the main contours of which are now entrenched in CAP of Ukraine, and, undoubtedly, will create the opportunities for forming of new scientific ideas and a theoretical model of administrative process as a court process.
|
Keywords | administrative court proceedings; administrative regulation; administrative acts; procedural form; public disputes; administrative relations; court protection, administrative procedure legislation |
References | Bibliography
Athored books 1. Ochendowski E, Postępowanie administracyjne i sądowoadministracyjne (Dom Organizatora 2000) (in Polish). 2. Pierce R and Shapiro S and Verkuil P, Administrative Law and Process (Foundation Press 1999) (in English). 3. Galligan D, Poljanskij V, Starilov Ju, Administrativnoe pravo: istorija razvitija i osnovnye sovremennye koncepcii [Administrative Law: History of Development and Basic Modern Concepts] (Jurist 2002) (in Russian).
Edited books 4. Galligan D (еd), A Reader on Administrative Law (Oxford University Press 1996) (in English). 5. Kozyrina A (rеd), Administrativnoe pravo zarubezhnyh stran: uchebnoe posobie [Administrative Law of Foreign Countries: Tutorial] (Spark 1996) (in Russian). 6. Kozyrina A i Shatinoj M (red), Administrativnoe pravo zarubezhnyh stran: uchebnik [Administrative Law of Foreign Countries: Textbook] (Spark 2003) (in Russian).
Journal articles 7. Aver’ianov V, ‘“Kruhlyi stil” z obhovorennia rezultativ ekspertyzy proektu Administratyvnoprotsesualnoho kodeksu Ukrainy’ [‘“Round Table” Discussing the Results of the Examination of the Draft Administrative Code of Ukraine’] (2003) 1 Pravo Ukrainy 47-153 (in Ukrainian). 8. Baklan O, ‘Zakordonnyi dosvid shchodo provadzhennia za zvernenniamy hromadian do orhaniv vykonavchoi vlady’ [‘Foreign Experience in Conducting Proceedings Against Citizens’ Appeals to Executive Bodies’] (2007) 1 Yurydychnyi visnyk 50-4 <http://law. nau.edu.ua/images/Nauka/Naukovij_jurnal/2007/statna_n1_2_2007/Baklan_50.pdf> (accessed: 22.02.2019) (in Ukrainian). 9. Holosnichenko I, ‘Pravove rehuliuvannia nadannia upravlinskykh posluh ta vyrishennia administratyvnykh sporiv’ [‘Legal Regulation of the Provision of Management Services and the Resolution of Administrative Disputes’] (2003) 10 Pravo Ukrainy 86-90 (in Ukrainian). 10. Kuzmenko O, ‘Heneza administratyvno-protsesualnoho prava’ [‘Genesis of Administrative Procedural Law’] (2004) 6 Pravo Ukrainy 21-4 (in Ukrainian). 11. Motruk T, ‘Poniattia administratyvnoi protsedury u spivvidnoshenni do poniattia administratyvnoho protsesu’ [‘Concept of Administrative Procedure in Relation to the Notion of Administrative Process’] (2017) 42 Naukovyi visnyk Uzhhorodskoho natsionalnoho universytetu. Seriia Pravo 186-9 <http://www.visnyk-juris.uzhnu.uz.ua/ file/No.42/45.pdf> (accessed: 22.02.2019) (in Ukrainian). 12. Shkolyk A, ‘Modeli systematyzatsii administratyvno-protsedurnoho zakonodavstva’ [‘Models of Systematization of Administrative-Procedural Legislation’] (2017) 64 Visnyk Lvivskoho universytetu. Seriia Yurydychna 111-8 (in Ukrainian). 13. Tihomirov Ju i drygie, ‘Administrativnye procedury dlja publichnoj vlasti i grazhdan’ [‘Administrative Procedures for Public Authority and Citizens’] (2002) 6 Zakonodatel’stvo i jekonomika 3-8 (in Russian). 14. Tihomirov Ju i Talapina Je, ‘Administrativnye procedury i pravo’ [‘Administrative Procedures and Law’] (2002) 4 Zhurnal rossijskogo prava 4-5 (in Russian).
Newspaper articles 15. Bilak M, ‘Pro protsedury i pretsedenty’ [‘About Procedures and Precedents’] (Dzerkalo tyzhnia, 1 chervnia 2018) <https://dt.ua/macrolevel/pro-proceduri-iprecedenti279530_.html> (accessed: 22.02.2019) (in Ukrainian).
Conference papers 16. Boiko I, ‘Bazovi katehorii prava administratyvnykh protsedur’ [‘Basic Categories of Law Administrative Procedures’] v Administratyvna protsedura: osoblyvosti formuvannia ukrainskoi kontseptsii: materialy dopovidei uchasnykiv Kruhloho stolu (m. Kharkiv, 15 veresnia 2017 r.) [Administrative Procedure: Features of the Formation of the Ukrainian Concept: Materials of Reports of Participants of the Round Table (Kharkiv, September 15, 2017)] (2017) 7-13 <http://www.aprnu.kharkiv.org/doc/Admin_procedura.pdf> (accessed: 22.02.2019) (in Ukrainian). 17. Shtelkens P, ‘Yurysdyktsiia administratyvnykh sudiv, yikh struktura i sklad’ [‘Jurisdiction of administrative courts, their structure and composition’] v Administratyvni protsedury i administratyvne sudochynstvo v Nimechchyni: zbirnyk materialiv [Administrative Procedures and Administrative Proceedings in Germany: Collection of Materials] (Nimrtskyi fond mizhnarodnoho pravovoho spivrobitnytstva) (2006) (in Ukrainian). 18. Stetsenko S, ‘Administratyvni protsedury: poniattia, oznaky, klasyfikatsiia’ [‘Administrative Procedures: Notions, Signs, Classification’] v Publichna sluzhba i administratyvne sudochynstvo: zdobutky i vyklyky: zbirnyk materialiv I Mizhnarodnoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii (Kyiv, 5-6 lypnia 2018 r.) [Public Service and Administrative Justice: Achievements and Challenges: Collection of Materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference (Kyiv, July 5-6, 2018)] 393-6 (in Ukrainian).
|
Electronic version | Download |