Responsive image
Article Attempted Annexation of Crimea and International Legal Practice
Authors
BORYS BABIN

Doctor of Law, Professor, Chief Researcher Institute of Legislation of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, expert of the Crimean Reintegration Association (Kyiv, Ukraine) ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9317-3845 babinb@ukr.net

 

Name of magazine Legal journal «Law of Ukraine» (Ukrainian version)
Issue 11 / 2020
Pages 40 - 48
Annotation

The article is devoted to the study of international legal practice of annexations and of attempted annexations in a modern international law. Various reflection of such acts of states in international law is proved and it is indicated that the condition for completion of the act of annexation is either its recognition by the international community and the subject of international law, which became the victim of annexation, or termination of such annexation; the classification of annexations and attempted annexations on full and partial is offered, features of annexation as a component of aggression are defined.

It turns out that since the use of force against Ukraine took place during the attempted annexation of Crimea, such Russian Federation’s attempted annexation is an element of the international crime of aggression, in particular reflected in the new version of the Rome Statute.

 It is pointed out that the use of the category of “attempted annexation” is possible not so much in relation to the status of Crimea, which according to international law and national law is the temporarily occupied territory of Ukraine, but primarily in relationto the characteristics of the aggressor State’s actions in Crimea. The use of the category “annexation” (rather than “attempted annexation”) in relation to the actions of the Russian Federation with regard to Crimea is inadmissible both in legislation and international acts and at the level of political statements or doctrine.

 

Keywords annexation; attempted annexation; territorial integrity; territorial claims; principles of international law
References

Bibliography

Journal articles

1. Zadorozhny O, ‘Umovy pravomirnosti setsessii iak zasobu realizatsii prava na samovyznachennya’ (2014) 17 Pravova derzhava 111–6 (in Ukrainian).

 

Websites

2. ‘Annexation’ (Cambridge Dictionary) <https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/ english/annexation> (accessed: 22.12.2020) (in English).

3. Shaoul J, ‘US recognizes Morocco’s annexation of Western Sahara’ <https://www.wsws. org/en/articles/2020/12/14/isra-d14.html> (accessed: 22.12.2020) (in English).

4. ‘Termin “aneksiya” khybny po vidnoshennu do Krymu ta supereshit ukrainskomu zakonodavstvu’ (Ministerstvo z pytan reintegratzii tymchasovo okupovanykh territoriy Ukrainy, 20.11.2020) <https://mtot.gov.ua/ua/termin-aneksija-hibni-po-vidnoshennjudo-krimu-ta-superechit-ukraiinskomu-zakonodavstvu> (accessed: 22.12.2020) (in Ukrainian).

 

Electronic version Download