Responsive image
Article The Doctrine of Private International Law in Ukraine at the Turn of the Century
Authors ANATOLII DOVGERT
Name of magazine Legal journal «Law of Ukraine» (Ukrainian version)
Issue 6 / 2020
Pages 13 - 40
Annotation

The process of codifying the provisions of private international law has become the major factor triggering the reinterpretation and development of its doctrine in modern Ukraine. When the codification project was prepared in the mid-1990s, it turned out that all the elements of the private international law theory, which was Soviet in essence, had to be thoroughly “sorted out”, like parts in a car engine. The codification efforts highlighted the need for changes, primarily of the approaches to the conflict-oflaws doctrine. Later, this had an effect on the shaping of new scientific ideas about other aspects of the paradigm of private international law.

The purpose of the article is to elaborate on the content of re-conceptualization of the private international law doctrine in Ukraine at the turn of the century as a result of successful codification of conflict of laws (conflict of laws and jurisdictions).

The author establishes that the domestic conflict of laws doctrine has been updated in the following areas: (i) switching of conflict of laws to the private-law basis; (ii) making of the conflict-of-laws provisions more flexible and, at the same time, maintaining theirdistinctness; (iii) “materialization” of the choi ce of law; (iv) adoption of the unilateral approach for dealing with a conflict-of-laws issue.

The author concludes that the Ukrainian “conflict-of-laws” codification at the turn of the century facilitated the transition of the domestic private international law doctrine to the theoretical platform of Western European countries and international organizations. By means of the principle, connecting factor and other facets of the closest connection, Ukrainian conflict of laws was actually rewritten anew. Currently it is characterized by high dispositivity, regulativity and flexibility. Having assimilated the modern multi-lateral method of the choice of law, which has been established to a great extent due to the efforts of F. Savigny, the domestic doctrine of private international law has not abandoned the elements of materialization of conflict of laws (its focus on the material result of a decision made in a particular case – material justice) and a unilateral approach to dealing with a conflict-of-laws issue. Today, the new domestic doctrine also offers the content of the main lines of recodification (updating) of private international law. The author believes that an important task of the update is to bring the codification back to the structure of the Civil Code of Ukraine in the form of the closing book on private international law.

 

Keywords private international law doctrine; conflict-of-laws rule; codification; Law of Ukraine “On Private International Law”; recodification of conflict of laws
References

Bibliography

Authored books

1. Butler W, Civil code of Ukraine and law of Ukraine on private international law (Wildy, Simmonds & Hill Pub 2011) (in English).

2. Symeonides S, Codifying Choice of Law Around the World: An International Comparative Analysis (Oxford University Press 2014) (in English).

3. Asoskov A, Osnovy kollizionnogo prava [Fundamentals of Conflict of Laws] (Infotropic Media 2013) (in Russian).

4. Zvekov V, Kollizii zakonov v mezdunarodnom chastnom prave [Conflict of Laws in Private International Law] (Wolters Kluwer 2007) (in Russian).

5. Lunts L, Mezdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo: uchebnik [Private International Law: Textbook] (Juridicheskoe izdatelstvo Ministerstva justitsii SSSR 1949) (in Russian).

6. Lunts L, Mezdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo [Private International Law] (Juridicheskaia literatura 1973) (in Russian).

7. Merezhko A, Lex mercatoria: teoriia i printsipy transnatsionalnogo torgovogo prava [Lex Mercatoria: Theory and Principles of Transnational Commercial Law] (Takson 1999) (in Russian). 8. Pereterskii I i Krylov S, Mezdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo [Private International Law] (Gocudarstvennoe izdatelstvo juridicheskoi literatury 1959) (in Russian).

 

Edited and translated books

9. Basedow J and Rühl G and Ferrari F and Asensio P (ed), Encyclopedia of Private International Law. Four Volume (Edward Elgar Publishing 2017) (in English).

10. Savigny F C von, Private International Law. A treatise on the conflict of laws and the limits of their operation in respect of place and time (transl by W Guthrie, Stevens and Sons 1880) (in English). 11. Boguslavskii M i Lisitsin-Svetlanov A i Trunk A (ed), Sovremennoe mezdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo Rossii i Evrosojuza: monografiia [Modern International Law of Russia and the European Union: Monograph] kn 1 (Norma 2013) (in Russian).

12. Dovgert A (red), Mezdunarodne pryvatne pravo. Aktualni problemy: monografiia [Private International Law. Topical Issues: Monograph] (Ukrainskii Tsentr pravnychyh studii 2001) (in Ukrainian).

13. Dovgert A (red), Miznarodne pryvatne pravo. Naukovo-practychnyi komentar Zakonu [Private International Law. Scientific and Practical Commentary on the Law] (Оdissei 2008) (in Ukrainian). 14. Dovgert A, Doctryna mezdunarodnogo chastnogo prava v suchasnii Ukraini [‘Private International Law Doctrine in Modern Ukraine’ in Legal Doctrine of Ukraine. Doctrine of Private Law of Ukraine], t 3 (Kuznetsova N red, Pravo 2013) (in Ukrainian).

15. Dovgert A (red), Dovidnyk zahyshenyh disertatsii z mezdunarodnogo chastnogo prava v Ukraini (1991–2012) [Directory of Defended Academic Degree Theses on Private International Law in Ukraine (1991–2012)] (Feniks 2013) (in Ukrainian).

16. Matveev G, Mezdunarodne pryvatne pravo [Private International Law] (Vyssha shkola 1985) (in Russian).

17. Raape L, Mezdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo [Private International Law] (per s nem, Izdatelstvo inostrannoi literatury 1960) (in Russian).

18. Savinji F, Sistema sovremennogo rimskogo prava [The System of Modern Roman Law], t І (per s nem, Statut 2011) (in Russian).

 

Journal articles

19. Dovgert A, ‘The Codification of Private International Law in Ukraine’ (2005) 7 Yearbook of Private International Law 131–59 (in English).

20. Dowgert A, ‘Ukrainskia kodyfikacja prawa prywatnego miedzynarodowego’ (2008) XVII (2) Kwartalnik prawa prywatnego 349–84 (in Polish).

21. Michaels R, ‘EU Law as Private International Law? Reconceptualising the Country-ofOrigin Principle as Vested-Rights Theory’ (2006) 2 Journal of Private International Law 195–242 (in English).

22. Dovgert A, ‘Nauka mizhnarodnoho pryvatnogo prava v nezalezhnii Ukraini’ (1991– 2012) [‘Private International Law Science in Independent Ukraine (1991-2012)’] (2013) 7 Pravo Ukrainy 12–23 (in Ukrainian).

23. Dovgert A, ‘Recodyfikatsiia Tsyvilnogo kodeksu Ukrainy: osnovni chynnyky I peredumovy’ [‘Recodification of the Civil Code of Ukraine: Major Factors and Prerequisites for the Start’] (2019) 1 Pravo Ukrainy 27–41 (in Ukrainian).

24. Zvekov V, ‘Zakon Ukrainy 2005 goda “O mezdunarodnom chastnom prave”’ [‘Law of Ukraine of 2005 “On Private International Law”’] (2006) 5 Hoziaistvo i pravo 119–29 (in Russian).

25. Еrpyljova N i Hetman-Pavlova I, ‘Stanovlenie i razvitie zakonodatelstva o mezdunarodnom chastnom prave Ukrainy’ [‘Establishment and Development of Legislation on Private International Law in Ukraine’] (2016) 3 Pravo. Zhurnal Vysshei shkoly ekonomiki 122–38 (in Russian).

26. Pereterskii I, ‘Ishodnye momenty mezdunarodnogo chastnogo prava’ [‘Starting Points of Private International Law of the RSFSR’] (1924) 3 Sovetskoe pravo 87–105 (in Russian).

 

Conference papers

27. Dovgert A, ‘Zmina paradigmy mezdunarodnogo pryvatnogo prava’ [‘Changing the Paradigm of Private International Law’] v Aktualni prolemy tsyvilnogo, simeinogo ta mezdunarodnogo pryvatnogo prava (Matveevski tsyvilistychni chitannia) [Topical Issues of Civil, Family and International Private Law (Matveev’s Civil Law Readings): Materials of International Scientific and Practical Conference] (Bilotserkivdruk, 2015) (in Ukrainian).

 

Thesis

28. Tsirat K, ‘Avtonomiia voli storin u Gaazkyh pryntsipah vyboru prava u mizhnarodnyh komertsiinyh dogovorah’ [‘Party Autonomy in the Hague Principles of the Choice of Law in International Commercial Contracts’] (avtoref dys kand yurid nauk, 2018) (in Ukrainian).

 

Websites

29. ‘Pryntsipyh vyboru prava u mizhnarodnyh komertsiinyh dogovorah’ [‘Principles of the Choice of Law in International Commercial Contracts’] <https://assets.hcch.net/docs/ a3b1d0ac-4b81-4330-8716-ab1ea96de790.pdf> (accessed: 21.05.2020) (in Ukrainian).

 

 

Electronic version Download