Responsive image
Article Doctrine of Criminal Law of Ukraine
Authors MYKOLA PANOV
Name of magazine Legal journal «Law of Ukraine» (Ukrainian version)
Issue 1 / 2022
Pages 81 - 104
Annotation

The article is devoted to the study of the main problems of the doctrine of criminal law, which has not yet received the necessary scientific research. Meanwhile, the provisions of the doctrine of criminal law (hereinafter – DCL) are important for clarifying the essence and content of criminal law and legislation: for their development, improving lawmaking and law enforcement, development of criminal law research. Purpose of the article: to develop the concept of “doctrine of criminal law”, to examine the constituent elements of the DCL, to identify its types and forms, to clarify the functions and impact of the DCL on criminal law regulation: the practice of criminal law and law enforcement, and to extending scientific knowledge and development research in the field of criminal law.Based on the research and analysis of the main essential features (characteristics) of the doctrine of criminal law as a branch of public law, formed its concept, which is proposed to understand the scientific legal concept, the content of which is a holistic and complex system fundamental (conceptional and basic) scientific and applied provisions of criminal law as its basis: essence, content, form, system, tasks, functions, principles and grounds of its formation and development, on criminal liability and its basis, criminal offenses – negative social legal phenomena – and penalties for them, as well as relatively optimal and reasonable rules and techniques of criminal law and law enforcement. At the same time, very important constituent elements of the content of the DCL are distinguished and considered, which differ in the form of external expression: principles of criminal law, scientific categories, criminal law postulates and other generalized fundamental legal provisions. These elements of the DCL are closely related, constitute the content (at the level of general) criminal law regulations and prohibitions and are enshrined (as a source) in criminal law institutions, norms, legal structures, other criminal law entities and determine their social-legal essence. The types of DCL are distinguished and considered: general and particular (partial or special), scientific, legal and official doctrines of criminal law. The functions of the doctrine are investigated: a) axiological; b) regulatory (in the field of criminal law and law enforcement); c) preventive and educational; d) scientific and information. On this basis, the scientific and practical significance of the doctrine of criminal law as a fundamental (basic) element of the criminal law system and criminal law, to ensure the implementation of their main functions: security, regulatory, preventive.

The main results of the study: the definition of the concept of “criminal law doctrine”, highlighted the constituent elements of the content of the criminal law, examined the types and functions of the criminal law, its impact on law enforcement practice of criminal law, development of criminal law research.

The conclusion summarizes the results obtained, the importance of the DCL to improve the practice (lawmaking and law enforcement) and the science of criminal law.

 

Keywords doctrine of criminal law; the concept of the doctrine of criminal law; elements of the content of the doctrine of criminal law: principles of criminal law, categories of criminal law, postulates of criminal law; some fundamental extended legal statements; general doctrine of criminal law; particular doctrine of criminal law (special or partial); scientific doctrine of criminal law; official doctrine of criminal law; functions of the doctrine of criminal law: axiological, regulatory, preventive and educational, scientific and informational
References

Bibliography

 

Authored books

 1. Alekseev S, Pravo v nashej zhizni (Jurid lit 1978) (in Russian).

2. Babaev V, Sovetskoe pravo kak logicheskaja sistema: uchebnoe posobie (1978) (in Russian).

3. Genrih V, Predmet i metod ugolovno-pravovogo regulirovanija: istorija, teorija i praktika (Norma: INFA – M 2011) (in Russian).

. Hatseliuk V, Realizatsiia pryntsypu zakonnosti kryminalnoho prava Ukrainy (zahalni zasady, kontseptsii (RVV LDUVS 2006) (in Ukrainian).

5. Semenikhin I, Pravova doktryna: zahalnoteoretychnyi analiz (seriia “Naukovi dopovidi” vyp. 2, 2012) (in Ukrainian).

6. Sukhodubova I, Stabilnist i dynamizm zakonodavstva: poniattia, spivvidnoshennia, zasoby zabezpechennia (Pravo 2016) (in Ukrainian).

7. Uvarova O, Pryntsypy prava u pravozastosuvanni: zahalnoteoretychna kharakterystyka (Drukarnia MADRYD 2012) (in Ukrainian).

8. Vasil’ev A, Pravovye kategorii. Metodologicheskie aspekty razrabotki sistemy kategorij teorii prava (1976) (in Russian).

9. Vladymyrov L, Kurs kryminalnoho prava: chastyna persha: Osnovy suchasnoho kryminalnoho prava (Vyd Palyvoda A V 2010) (in Ukrainian).

 

Journal articles

10. Bazhanov M, ‘K voprosu o preemstvennosti v ugolovnom prave’ (1995) 30 Problemy zakonnosti 114–121 (in Russian).

11. Maksimov S, ‘Pravova doktryna: filosofsko-pravovyi pidkhid’ (2013) 9 Pravo Ukrainy (in Ukrainian).

12. Oborotov Yu, ‘Pravoporozuminnia yak aksiomatychne nachalo (postulat) prava’ (2010) 4 Pravo Ukrainy (in Ukrainian).

13. Panov M, ‘Funktsionalnyi pidkhid – neobkhidna skladova metodolohii naukovykh dosiahnen kryminalnoho prava’ (2017) 2 Pravo Ukrainy 14–22 (in Ukrainian).

14. Panov M, ‘Poniatiinyi aparat kryminalnoho prava ta yoho naukove i praktychne znachennia’ (2018) 4 Pravo Ukrainy 205–22 (in Ukrainian).

15. Panov M, ‘Systemnyi pidkhid u kryminalnomu pravi ta problemy udoskonalennia kryminalnoho zakonodavstva’ (2012) 6 Pravo Ukrainy 227–41 (in Ukrainian).

16. Semenikhin I, ‘Pravova doktryna: poniattia, znaky, struktura’ (2016) 142 Problemy zakonnosti 26–36 (in Ukrainian).

17. Tatsii V, Tiutiuhin V, Ponomarenko Yu, ‘Problemy stabilnosti y dynamizmu kryminalnoho zakonodavstva Ukrainy na suchasnomu etapi’ [2015] 4 (83) Visnyk Nats. akad. prav. nauk Ukrainy 54–66 (in Ukrainian). Dictionaries and Encyclopedias 18. ‘Pravova doktryna’ v Velyka ukrainska yurydychna entsyklopediia, t 3: Zahalna teoriia prava (Petryshyn O holova red kol, Pravo 2017) 471–7 (in Ukrainian).

19. Filosofija: Jenciklopedicheskij slovar (Ivin A red, Gardarika 2004) (in Russian).

20. Filosofskij jenciklopedicheskij slovar (Il’ichev L gl redakcija, Jenciklopedija 1983) (in Russian). 21. Kandakov N, Logicheskij slovar’-spravochnik (Nauka 1976) (in Russian).

22. Oborotov Yu, ‘Postulaty prava’ v Velyka Ukrainska yurydychna entsyklopediia, t 2: Filosofiia prava (Maksymov S holova redkol, Pravo 2017) (in Ukrainian).

23. Shepitko M, Kryminalna yustytsiia v latynskykh vyslovakh i terminakh: slovnyk-dovidnyk (Pravo 2020) (in Ukrainian).

24. Universalnyi slovnyk ukrainskoi leksyky. Synonimy, antonimy, omonimy (Nechvolod L, Bezditko V, Parashchych V uklad, Torchsin plius 2011) (in Ukrainian).

25. Velykyi tlumachnyi slovnyk ukrainskoi movy (Busel V uklad i holov red, Perun 2001) (in Ukrainian).

 

Electronic version Download