Responsive image
Article Legal Values of the European Union and Their Impact on National Legal Orders
Authors
NATALIIA KAMINSKA
Doctor of Jurisprudence, Professor, Leading Researcher of the Institute of State and Law named after V. M. Koretsky National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, professor of the Department of International and European Law of the National Aviation University (Kyiv, Ukraine) ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0466-9428 na-pro@ukr.net
Name of magazine Legal journal «Law of Ukraine» (Ukrainian version)
Issue 7 / 2024
Pages 56 - 77
Annotation

The purpose of this article is a comprehensive study of the nature and essence of legal values, general theoretical analysis, determination of the characteristics of the values and principles of the European Union, as well as the impact on national legal systems and integration processes. Their multifaceted and interdisciplinary nature is emphasized, which leads to the use of various methodological tools, general scientific and special legal methods (in particular, axiological, dialectical, phenomenological, anthropological, epistemological, comparative legal, historical, etc.), complex and systemic, comparativist, other approaches and principles 
Emphasis is placed on the nature, signs and typology of legal values through the prism of Ukrainian and foreign scientific work, their constitutional and legal regulation in Ukraine and foreign states as a result of the evolution of national legal traditions, the basis of the Europeanization of national legal systems, the process of joining the EU. The essence of legal values, principles of the EU, their contractual and legal and institutional mechanisms of ensuring in supranational and national legal systems are analyzed. The role of the bodies of constitutional jurisdiction, along with other authorized ones, in ensuring the implementation of EU legal values is singled out. Given the general civilizational character, the accumulation of state-building and legal traditions, the best practices of legal reforms, and the globalization potential of the studied values, their further study and implementation in various spheres and levels, including in countering modern threats and challenges. 
 

Keywords legal values; European Union; EU law; principles of law; freedom; human rights; security; national legal order; supranationality; legal axiology; European integration; legal influence
References

Bibliography
Edited and translated books 
1. Konstytutsiia Italiiskoi Respubliky (z peredmovoiu V. Shapovala 2018). 
2. Konstytutsiia Frantsuzkoi Respubliky (z peredmovoiu Volodymyra Shapovala 2018). 
3. Ontolohiia, aksiolohiia, antropolohiia, hnoseolohiia filosofsko-pravovykh vchen: navchalnyi posibnyk (V Kuzmenko red, Lira 2015). 

Journal articles 
4. Bandura O, Lytvynov O, Maksymov S, Pavlyshyn O, Smaznova I, ‘Semiotics of law in modern philosophical and legal research’ [2022] 40(72) Cuestiones Politicas 89–107. 
5. Dzhuska A, Kaminska N, Makarukha Z, ‘Modern concept of understanding the human right to life’ Wiadomości Lekarskie [2021] 74(2) 1337–42. 
6. Shaptala N, Kaminska N, Ivanochko I, Kulyk T, ‘Constitutionalism as a philosophical and legal category and a socio-political phenomenon’ [2020] 23(2) Journal of Legal, Ethical and Regulatory Issues. 
7. Boichuk D, Hoi A, ‘Protsedura vstupu Ukrainy ta Polshchi do Yevropeiskoho Soiuzu: istorychno-pravovyi analiz’ [2021] 11 Yurydychnyi naukovyi elektronnyi zhurnal <http:// lsej.org.ua/11_2021/201.pdf> (accessed 02.07.2024). 
8. Ivashev Ye, ‘Vplyv aksiolohii prava na rozvytok teorii prav liudyny’ [2013] 1 Naukovyi visnyk Natsionalnoi akademii vnutrishnikh sprav 112–20. 
9. Kaminska N, ‘Suchasna paradyhma konstytutsiinykh tsinnostei ta yikh znachennia v umovakh voiennoho stanu’ [2022] 2(24) Filosofski ta metodolohichni problemy prava 86–95. 
10. Kolisnyk V, Berchenko H, Slinko T, ‘Konstytutsiina identychnist yak vtilennia ustanovchoi vlady’ [2022] 29(3) Visnyk Natsionalnoi akademii pravovykh nauk Ukrainy 69–88. 
11. Krusian A, ‘Polityko-pravovi tsinnosti suchasnoho ukrainskoho konstytutsionalizmu (v konteksti aksiolohichnoho vymiru konstytutsiinoho prava)’ [2012] 45 Aktualni problemy polityky 3–13. 
12. Pavlyshyn O, Nevidomyi V, ‘Mistse idei myru v systemi elementiv idei prava’ [2022] 1(23) Filosofski ta metodolohichni problemy prava 35–43. 
13. Renov Ye, ‘Pravovi tsinnosti: pryroda, znachennia ta pytannia akulturatsii v aspekti yevrointehratsii Ukrainy’ [2021] 4 Amparo 63–9. 
14. Savchyn M, ‘Konstytutsiini tsinnosti ta konstytutsiina yurysprudentsiia v Ukraini’ [2010] 1 Visnyk Konstytutsiinoho Sudu Ukrainy 111–20. 
15. Slinko T, Tkachenko Ye, ‘Harantuvannia konstytutsiinoi natsionalnoi identychnosti orhanamy konstytutsiinoho kontroliu’ [2023] 7 Pravo Ukrainy 70–84. 
16. Yukhymiuk O, ‘Pravo YeS ta yoho pryntsypy v rishenniakh Konstytutsiinoho Trybunalu Respubliky Polshcha pered vstupom u YeS: dosvid dlia Ukrainy’ [2022] 2(6) Nove ukrainske pravo 215–21. 

Conference papers 
17. Kofman B, Kurovska I, Semenova A, ‘Leading Approaches in Maintenance of International Peace and Security’ in: W Strielkowski (eds), Sustainable Leadership for Entrepreneurs and Academics (Springer 2019) 511–9. 
18. Žalimas D, ‘EU Law in National Constitutional Paradigm: Lithuanian Experience’ Konstytutsiine pravo YeS v aspekti yevrointehratsii Ukrainy: tezy dopovidei Mizhnar. naukovoprakt. konfer. (KhNU imeni V. N. Karazina 2023) 13–19.
19. Hladkyi S, ‘Pravovi tsinnosti yak praktychna problema pravovoho zhyttia ukrainskoho suspilstva’ Tradytsii ta innovatsii rozvytku pryvatnoho prava v Ukraini: osvitnii vymir: materialy VIII Vseukrainskoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii (PUET 2020) 10–3. 
20. Kahanovska T, ‘Ievropeiskyi pravoporiadok yak proiav bahatorivnevoho konstytutsionalizmu’ Konstytutsiine pravo YeS v aspekti yevrointehratsii Ukrainy: tezy dopovidei Mizhnar. naukovoprakt. konfer. (KhNU imeni V. N. Karazina 2023) 4–9. 
21. Pavlyshyn O, ‘Spravedlyvist yak pravova tsinnist’ Science, theory and practice: International Scientific and Practical Conference (Tokyo 2021) 210–2. 
22. Serohin V, ‘Konstytutsiine pravo Yevropeiskoho Soiuzu yak zakonomirnyi rezultat konstytutsionalizatsii yoho pravovoho poriadku’ Konstytutsiine pravo YeS v aspekti yevrointehratsii Ukrainy: tezy dopovidei Mizhnar. naukovo-prakt. konfer. (KhNU imeni V. N. Karazina 2023) 65–68. 
23. Voronov M, ‘Pravova pryroda yevropeiskoho konstytutsionalizmu’ Konstytutsiine pravo YeS v aspekti yevrointehratsii Ukrainy: tezy dopovidei Mizhnar. naukovo-prakt. konfer. (KhNU imeni V. N. Karazina 2023) 41–3. 

Theses 
24. Bandura O, ‘Iednist tsinnostei ta istyny u pravi (filosofskyi analiz)’ (dys d-ra filos nauk 2003). 25. Lypovets Yu, ‘Pravovi tsinnosti yak idealy ta kompromisy’ (avtoref dys kand yuryd nauk 2021). 
26. Zhebrovska K, ‘Pravovi tsinnosti u vzaiemodii pravovykh system’ (avtoref dys kand yuryd nauk 2017).
 

Electronic version Download