Responsive image
Article title Development and Research of the Doctrine of Ukrainian Statehood in the Historical and Legal Literature of the Era of Ukraine’s Independence
Authors
VOLODYMYR GRECHENKO
Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor, Head of the Department of Humanities and Ukrainian Studies, Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs, Honored Worker of Education of Ukraine (Kharkiv, Ukraine) ORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-6046-0178 grechenko18@gmail.com
Magazine name Legal journal «Law of Ukraine» (Ukrainian version)
Magazine number 4 / 2025
Pages 148 - 163
Annotation

The article highlights the genesis of the problem of the formation of the concept of the history of Ukrainian statehood in the scientific literature during the years of Ukraine’s independence.

The purpose of the article. The author set himself the goal of investigating the state and prospects of studying the current scientific problem – “history of Ukrainian statehood” during the period of Ukraine’s independence.

This goal is specified in the following tasks: to determine the periodization of the study of this problem; to analyze the main achievements of domestic historical and legal literature in the development of the doctrine of the history of Ukrainian statehood; to characterize the prospects for further scientific research in the study of the problem of the history of Ukrainian statehood.

 Methodological basis. The application of the principle of historicism allowed us to consider all historical facts, phenomena and events in accordance with specific historical circumstances, in their interconnection and interdependence. All historical phenomena were studied in development: how they arose, what stages they went through in their development, what they ultimately became. Events or individuals, their activities were not considered simultaneously or abstractly, outside of time dimensions.

The problem-chronological method was used to consider historical processes and phenomena from the point of view of their problematic nature and chronological sequence.

The article emphasizes the political, scientific and educational significance of the problem of the history of Ukrainian statehood, its connection with the current problems of life in modern Ukraine. This is especially relevant today, during the period of aggression of the Russian quasi-empire against Ukraine and its desire to destroy our state and bleed the Ukrainian nation. The author identified 3 periods in the development of the history of Ukrainian statehood as a scientific problem, the first of which begins with the publication with the participation of the prominent legal historian Volodymyr Kulchytsky (1919–2009), in whose honor the Scientific Center of Ukrainian Statehood is named. During the more than 30-year period of development of this problem, the main aspects of the doctrine of Ukrainian statehood were formulated, its periods, which were given a detailed and objective characteristic by a number of authoritative authors.

Keywords Ukraine; Ukrainian statehood; state; nation-building; Rus’
References

Bibliography
Authored books 
1. Anishchuk N, Istoriia i perspektyvy ukrainskoi derzhavnosti: navch.-metod. posib (Iurydychna literatura 2021) (in Ukrainian). 
2. Hurzhii O, Chukhlib T, Hetmanska Ukraina (Alternatyvy 1999) (in Ukrainian). 
3. Kotliar M, Kulchytskyi S, Dovidnyk z istorii Ukrainy (Ukraina 1996) (in Ukrainian). 
4. Kulchytskyi V, Nastiuk M, Tyshchyk B, Z istorii ukrainskoi derzhavnosti (Svit 1992) (in Ukrainian). 5. Miroshnychenko M, Derzhavnist i pravo Ukrainy: henezys u yevropeiskomu konteksti (Z naidavnishykh chasiv do pochatku XIX st.) (Atika 2006) (in Ukrainian). 
6. Shevchuk V, Kozatska derzhava: etiudy do istorii ukrainskoho derzhavotvorennia (Abrys 1995) (in Ukrainian). 
7. Todyka Ju, Osnovy konstitucionnogo stroja Ukrainy (Fakt 1999) (in Russian). 

Edited and translated books 
8. Istoriia derzhavy i prava Ukrainy: navch. posib. (A Chaikovskyi red, Yurinkom Inter 2000) (in Ukrainian). 
9. Plokhii S, Pokhodzhennia slov’ianskykh natsii: domoderni identychnosti v Ukraini, Rosii ta Bilorusii (per z anhl, Krytyka 2015) 456 (in Ukrainian). 
10. Snaider T, Peretvorennia natsii. Polshcha, Ukraina, Lytva, Bilorus.1569–1999 (per z anhl, Dukh i litera 2021) (in Ukrainian). 
11. Ukrainska derzhavnist. Istoryko-pravnychi narysy (S Kubiv, O Sviatotskyi kerivnyky proiektu, V Smolii zah red, Pravo Ukrainy 2021) (in Ukrainian). 

Journal articles 
12. Boiko I, ‘Peredumovy stanovlennia i rozvytok Kyievo-Ruskoi derzhavy: istoryko-pravovi aspekty’ [2025] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 70–93 (in Ukrainian). 
13. Boiko I, ‘Rozvytok prava yak vazhlyvoi oznaky Halytsko-Volynskoi derzhavy (1199– 1349 roky)’ [2020] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 97–115 (in Ukrainian). 
14. Boiko I, ‘Vstup do aktualnoi temy. Pytannia kontseptsii naukovoi doktryny Ukrainskoi derzhavnosti’ [2024] 12 Pravo Ukrainy 9–17 (in Ukrainian). 
15. Boiko I, Kovalchuk I, Zaiats O, ‘Dzherela prava Skifskoi derzhavy ta yikh znachennia dlia rozvytku derzhavotvorchykh protsesiv na terytorii Ukrainy’ [2024] 12 Pravo Ukrainy 50–65 (in Ukrainian). 
16. Havrylenko O, ‘Demokratychni tradytsii antychnykh polisiv Pivnichnoho Prychornomor’ia ta yikh vplyv na maibutni derzhavotvorchi protsesy na terytorii Ukrainy’ [2024] 12 Pravo Ukrainy 66–84 (in Ukrainian). 
17. Havrylenko O, ‘Zarodzhennia prava na terytorii Ukrainy v antychnu dobu’ [2020] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 64–84 (in Ukrainian). 
18. Holovko O, ‘Mistse ukrainskoho prava u pravovykh systemakh Rosiiskoi ta Avstriiskoi (Avstro-Uhorskoi) imperii’ [2020] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 159–179 (in Ukrainian). 
19. Hrechenko V, ‘Do pytannia pro sutnist poniattia “derzhavnist”’ [2002] 20 Visnyk Natsionalnoho universytetu vnutrishnikh sprav 248 (in Ukrainian). 
20. Hutiv B, ‘Stanovlennia i rozvytok derzhavy antiv yak pershoi formy ukrainskoho derzhavotvorennia’ [2025] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 45–55 (in Ukrainian). 
21. Kobyletskyi M, ‘Vplyv yevropeiskykh dzherel prava na rozvytok pravovoi systemy KyievoRuskoi derzhavy’ [2025] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 94–109 (in Ukrainian). 
22. Kolbenko A, ‘Zvychaieve pravo Zaporozkoi sichi yak vazhlyvyi etap ukrainskoi derzhavnosti’ [2020] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 129–139 (in Ukrainian). 
23. Kovalova S, ‘Mistse ukrainskoho prava u pravovii systemi Velykoho kniazivstva Lytovskoho ta Rechi Pospolytoi’ [2020] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 116–128 (in Ukrainian). 
24. Matseliukh I, ‘Bosporske tsarstvo ta yoho vplyv na stanovlennia Ukrainskoi derzhavnosti’ [2024] 12 Pravo Ukrainy 85–94 (in Ukrainian). 
25. Mernyk A, Yarova A, ‘Poniattia derzhava ta derzhavnist: zmist ta spivvidnoshennia (istorykopravovyi aspekt)’ [2019] 3 Yurydychnyi naukovyi elektronnyi zhurnal 19–22 (in Ukrainian). 
26. Oliinyk Yu, ‘Skifska derzhava ta yii mistse v istorii ukrainskoho derzhavotvorennia (VII–III st. do n. e.)’ [2024] 12 Pravo Ukrainy 32–49 (in Ukrainian). 
27. Savuliak R, ‘Halytsko-Volynska derzhava – spadkoiemnytsia Kyievo-Ruskoi derzhavy ta nastupnytsia tradytsii retseptsii rymskoho prava (ХII – persha polovyna ХIV st.)’ [2025] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 110–128 (in Ukrainian). 
28. Semkiv V, ‘Metodolohichni aspekty istoryko-pravovoi doktryny ukrainskoi derzhavnosti’ [2020] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 41–51 (in Ukrainian). 
29. Shevchuk L, Shevchuk T, ‘Osnovopolozhni zasady ta chynnyky formuvannia natsionalnoi pravovoi systemy Ukrainskoi kozatskoi derzhavy – Hetmanshchyny’ [2020] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 140–158 (in Ukrainian). 
30. Shevchuk L, Shevchuk T, ‘Vytoky ukrainskoho derzhavotvorennia epokhy Velykoho pereselennia narodiv: kontseptualni istoryko-pravovi osnovy’ [2025] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 25–44 (in Ukrainian). 
31. Shchodra O, ‘Skandynavskyi mif pro utvorennia Rusi ta istorychna osnova lehendy pro zasnuvannia Kyieva’ [2025] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 56–69 (in Ukrainian). 
32. Sviatotskyi O, Boiko I, ‘Vytoky, etapy stanovlennia ta rozvytok ukrainskoi derzhavnosti’ [2020] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 17–40 (in Ukrainian). 
33. Terliuk I, ‘Hotska derzhavnist na ukrainskykh zemliakh: polityko-pravova pryroda, sotsialna struktura ta istorychnyi vplyv’ [2025] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 9–24 (in Ukrainian). 
34. Terliuk I, ‘Kimmeriitsi yak pershi vidomi nosii derzhavnosti na terytorii suchasnoi Ukrainy’ [2024] 12 Pravo Ukrainy 18–31 (in Ukrainian).
35. Terliuk I, ‘Stanovlennia ukrainskoho natsionalnoho zakonodavstva u sferi sotsialnoekonomichnykh vidnosyn (1917–1921 roky)’ [2020] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 180–196 (in Ukrainian). 
36. Tyshchyk B, ‘Rozvytok prava u Zakhidnoukrainskii Narodnii Respublitsi (1918–1919 roky)’ [2020] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 197–211 (in Ukrainian). 
37. Yermolaiev V, ‘Stanovlennia ukrainskoho prava ta yoho vplyv na derzhavotvorchi protsesy v Kyivskii Rusi’ [2020] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 85–96 (in Ukrainian). 
38. Zakharchenko P, ‘Istoriia ukrainskoho prava: poniattieva, istoriohrafichna ta komparatyvistychna skladovi yii identyfikatsii’ [2020] 1 Pravo Ukrainy 52–63 (in Ukrainian). 

Encyclopedias 
39. Boiko O, ‘Derzhavnist’ (Velyka ukrainska entsyklopediia) <https://vue.gov.ua/Derzhavnist> (accessed 20.04.2025) (in Ukrainian). 
40. Shemshuchenko Yu, ‘Derzhavnist’, Yurydychna entsyklopediia: u 6 t. T. 2: D–Y (Iu Shemshuchenko vidp red, Ukrainska entsyklopediia im. M. P. Bazhana 1998) 16 (in Ukrainian). 

Theses 
41. Terliuk I, ‘Ukrainska natsionalna derzhavnist: formuvannia derzhavno-pravovoi tradytsii (druha polovyna XVI – pochatok XX st.)’ (dys doktora yuryd nauk, 2021) (in Ukrainian).

 Conference papers 
42. Dubrovska I, ‘Z istorii idei ukrainskoi derzhavnosti’, Ukrainska derzhavnist: stanovlennia, dosvid, problemy: zb. nauk. st. (za materialamy XII Kharkivskykh politolohichnykh chytan) (Iu Bytiak, O Sakhan uporiad, M Panov vidp red, Pravo 2001) 7 (in Ukrainian).

 Newspaper articles 
43. Zvernennia do natsii, do parlamentu trokh pershykh Prezydentiv Ukrainy (Holos Ukrainy 16 liutoho 2018) (in Ukrainian). 
44. Kubiv S, Sereda O, ‘Symvol natsionalnoi i politychnoi zrilosti‘ (Holos Ukrainy 28 lypnia 2022, № 154) 3 (in Ukrainian). 
45. Sviatotskyi O, ‘Ukrainska derzhavnist: poniattia, osnovni oznaky, symvoly, atrybuty, vytoky ta etapy stanovlennia’ (Holos Ukrainy 23 liutoho 2019) (in Ukrainian). 

Websites 
46. Vidbulosia cherhove zasidannia prezydii Natsionalnoi akademii pravovykh nauk Ukrainy <https://nals.com.ua/news/vidbulosya-chergove-zasidannya-prezydiyi-naczionalnoyiakademiyipravovyh-nauk-ukrayiny-4> (accessed 20.04.2025) (in Ukrainian)
 

Electronic version Download