| Article title | The Constitutional Model of State Resilience under the Transformation of the Global Legal Order: Concept, Measurement, Directions of Constitutionalization. |
|---|---|
| Authors |
Vasyl Kuybida
Doctor of Public Administration, Professor, Chief Research Fellow at the Department of Public Administration and Administrative Law, V. M. Koretsky Institute of State and Law of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine (Kyiv, Ukraine) ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7564-4706 kuybida58@gmail.com
|
| Journal name | Legal journal «Law of Ukraine» (Ukrainian version) |
| Journal issue | 9 / 2026 |
| Pages | 105 - 120 |
| Received | 26.08.2026 |
| Accepted | 28.09.2026 |
| Published | 30.09.2026 |
| Abstract | The article examines the adaptation of Ukraine as a complex socio-territorial system to fundamental changes in the strategic environment caused by the crisis of the global spatial order (the “Nomos of the Earth”) and the emergence of a multipolar world. The gap between the pace of change and the pace of the state’s adaptation is treated as a threat to sovereignty, and its overcoming – as a phase transition requiring constitutional support. The purpose of the article is to substantiate the concept, structure and measurement system of the constitutional model of state resilience as a constitutional response to this transformation. The methodology combines the systems approach, transnational legal orders theory, the comparative method and the content-validity procedure. The article defines the constitutional model of resilience through the functions of shock absorption, adaptation and recovery; reveals its correlation with the concepts of the Constitution of Ukraine and its five-block structure. It is established that resilience is already a category of Ukrainian state policy, yet its legal framework remains sub-constitutional, reactive and fragmented. Based on ECtHR case law, a four-criteria test for protective mechanisms is substantiated. Eight characteristics of a competitive society are operationalized; an integral index and a dynamic phase-transition criterion are proposed. The Russian appropriation of the nomos concept is refuted. It is concluded that constitutionalizing the resilience model should become the core of renewing the Fundamental Law after martial law ends. |
| Keywords | constitutional model of resilience; strategic environment; phase transition; adaptive governance capacity; transnational legal order; rule of law; anomie; constitutional reform |
| References | Authored books 1. Ashby W R, An Introduction to Cybernetics (Chapman & Hall 1956). 2. Bartel F, The Triumph of Broken Promises: The End of the Cold War and the Rise of Neoliberalism (Harvard University Press 2022). 3. Elkins Z, T Ginsburg, J Melton, The Endurance of National Constitutions (Cambridge University Press 2009) https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511817595. 4. Laruelle M, Russian Eurasianism: An Ideology of Empire (Woodrow Wilson Center Press 2008). 5. Mazarr M J, A Dale-Huang, J Deak et al, The Fates of Nations: Varieties of Success and Failure for Great Powers in Long-Term Rivalries (RAND Corporation 2024) (accessed 13.07.2026). 6. Mazarr M J, The Societal Foundations of National Competitiveness (RAND Corporation 2022) https://doi.org/10.7249/RRA499-1. 7. Schmitt C, The Nomos of the Earth in the International Law of the Jus Publicum Europaeum (transl. by G L Ulmen, Telos Press 2003). 8. Schmitt C, Völkerrechtliche Großraumordnung mit Interventionsverbot für raumfremde Mächte: Ein Beitrag zum Reichsbegriff im Völkerrecht (4. Aufl, Deutscher Rechtsverlag 1941). 9. Duhyn A, Osnovy heopolytyky: heopolytycheskoe budushchee Rossyy (Arktoheia 1997) (in Russian). Edited and translated books 10. Craig P, ‘Transnational Constitution-Making: The Contribution of the Venice Commission on Law and Democracy’, G Shaffer, T Ginsburg, T C Halliday (eds), Constitution-Making and Transnational Legal Order (Cambridge University Press 2019) 156–187. 11. Ginsburg T, Halliday T C, Shaffer G, ‘Constitution-Making as Transnational Legal Ordering’, G Shaffer, T Ginsburg, T C Halliday (eds), Constitution-Making and Transnational Legal Order (Cambridge University Press 2019) 1–26. 12. Landau D, ‘Democratic Erosion and Constitution-Making Moments: The Role of Transnational Legal Norms’ G Shaffer, T Ginsburg, T C Halliday (eds), Constitution-Making and Transnational Legal Order (Cambridge University Press 2019) 234–260. 13. Saati A, ‘Participatory Constitution-Making as a Transnational Legal Norm: Why Does It “Stick” in Some Contexts and Not in Others?’, G Shaffer, T Ginsburg, T C Halliday (eds), Constitution-Making and Transnational Legal Order (Cambridge University Press 2019) 261– 290. 14. Scheppele K L, ‘Autocracy under Cover of the Transnational Legal Order’, G Shaffer, T Ginsburg, T C Halliday (eds), Constitution-Making and Transnational Legal Order (Cambridge University Press 2019) 188–233. 15. Diurkhaim E, Samohubstvo: sotsiolohichne doslidzhennia (per. z fr. L Kononovycha, Osnovy 1998) (in Ukrainian). 16. Nort D, Instytutsii, instytutsiina zmina ta funktsionuvannia ekonomiky (I Dziub (per. z anhl.), Osnovy 2000) (in Ukrainian). 17. Ostrom E, Keruvannia spilnym: evoliutsiia instytutsii kolektyvnoi dii (per. z anhl., Nash chas 2012) (in Ukrainian). 18. Patnam R D, Leonard R, Nanetti R, Tvorennia demokratii: tradytsii hromadianskoi aktyvnosti v suchasnii Italii (per. z anhl., Osnovy 2001) (in Ukrainian). 19. Rabinovych P (red), Pryntsyp verkhovenstva prava: problemy teorii ta praktyky (Spolom 2016) (in Ukrainian). 20. Snaider T, Shliakh do nesvobody: Rosiia, Yevropa, Ameryka (H Herasym (per. z anhl.), Choven 2020) (in Ukrainian).
21. Vaitszekker fon E U, A Viikman, Come On! Kapitalizm, nedalekohliadnist, naselennia i ruinuvannia planety: dopovid Rymskoho klubu (per. z anhl., Samit-Knyha 2019) (in Ukrainian). 22. Zeikhan P, Kinets svitu – lyshe pochatok. Kartohrafuvannia krakhu hlobalizatsii (O Chupa (per. z anhl.), Laboratoriia 2025) (in Ukrainian). Journal articles 23. Adcock R, Collier D, ‘Measurement Validity: A Shared Standard for Qualitative and Quantitative Research’ [2001] 95(3) American Political Science Review 529–546 https://doi. org/10.1017/S0003055401003100. 24. Holling C S, ‘Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems’ [1973] 4 Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 1–23 https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.es.04.110173.000245. 25. Kuibida S, Kuybida V, ‘Today’s Priority Tasks Are the Modernization of Ukraine’ [2022] 02(34) Social and Human Sciences. Polish-Ukrainian Scientific Journal (accessed 10.07.2026). 26. Loewenstein K, ‘Militant Democracy and Fundamental Rights, I’ [1937] 31(3) American Political Science Review 417–432 https://doi.org/10.2307/1948164. 27. Loewenstein K, ‘Militant Democracy and Fundamental Rights, II’ [1937] 31(4) American Political Science Review 638–658 https://doi.org/10.2307/1948103. 28. Duhyn A, ‘Karl Shmytt: 5 urokov dlia Rossyy’ [1992] 7 Nash Sovremennyk (in Russian). 29. Koziubra M, ‘Verkhovenstvo prava i Ukraina’ [2012] 1–2 Pravo Ukrainy 30–63 (in Ukrainian). Conference papers 30. Kuibida S, Kuibida V, ‘Sohodnishni priorytetni zavdannia modernizatsii Ukrainy’, Publichne upravlinnia ta administruvannia v umovakh viiny i v postvoiennyi period v Ukraini: materialy Vseukr. nauk.-prakt. konf. u trokh tomakh, T. 3. (DZVO “UMO” NAPN Ukrainy 2022) 125– 137 (in Ukrainian). Websites 31. Fragile States Index 2024: Annual Report – A World Adrift (The Fund for Peace 2025) (accessed 12.07.2026). 32. Global Trends 2040: A More Contested World (National Intelligence Council 2021) 156 (accessed 10.07.2026). 33. Grabenwarter C, ‘Constitutional Resilience’ (Verfassungsblog 6 December 2018) (accessed 10.07.2026). 34. Tõnurist P, Hanson A, ‘Anticipatory Innovation Governance: Shaping the Future through Proactive Policy Making’ [2020] 44 OECD Working Papers on Public Governance https:// doi.org/10.1787/cce14d80-en. 35. Ekonomichnyi indeks verkhovenstva prava: chomu Ukraina nedootrymuie chvert VVP? (Rubryka, 3 kvitnia 2024) (accessed 10.07.2026) (in Ukrainian). 36. Komentar Natsionalnoho banku shchodo zminy realnoho VVP u 2025 rotsi (Natsionalnyi bank Ukrainy, 19 ber. 2026) (accessed 10.07.2026) (in Ukrainian). 37. Sobolev O, Ukrainska viziia. Yak pidhotuvaty ekonomiku do vidbudovy (Ekonomichna pravda, 3 kvitnia 2024) (accessed 10.07.2026) (in Ukrainian). |
| Electronic version | Download |