| Article title | Constitutional Human Rights in Legal Education in Ukraine and Germany. |
|---|---|
| Authors |
Serhii Rabinovych
Doctor of Legal Sciences, Professor, Professor at the Department of Constitutional Law, Ivan Franko National University of Lviv (Lviv, Ukraine) ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4144-5439 serg_rabin@yahoo.com
|
| Journal name | Legal journal «Law of Ukraine» (Ukrainian version) |
| Journal issue | 9 / 2026 |
| Pages | 147 - 165 |
| Received | 26.08.2026 |
| Accepted | 28.09.2026 |
| Published | 30.09.2026 |
| Abstract | The special place of human rights in constitutional law is due primarily to their value status and control and criterion function, since the compliance of the law with human rights principles and norms of the constitution is one of the cornerstones of its constitutionality. The purpose of the article is to provide a comparative description of models of studying human rights as a mandatory educational component in constitutional/“state” law courses at leading universities in Ukraine and Germany. The study of state law at German universities is characterized by the use of a model (a) Staatsrecht І–ІІ, in which the organizational and legal foundations of public power and constitutional human rights are two equivalent components of the aforementioned course and (b) Staatsrecht І–ІІ–ІІІ, in which the separate educational component is the issue of the interaction of constitutional law with international law. In Ukrainian universities, there are the following options for the ratio of the relative importance of human rights issues with other educational components: (I) Constitutional human rights and organizational and legal principles of public authority are equivalent components of the constitutional law course and, in addition, the study of international human rights standards is ensured; (II) Constitutional law and human rights (national and international) are independent educational components; (III) Human rights topics and issues are included in the constitutional law course and, in addition, the international protection of human rights is studied; (IV) The constitutional law course includes a thematic block on human rights; (V) The constitutional law course includes only a topic on the legal status of a person and a citizen. |
| Keywords | constitutional (state) law as an academic discipline; national human rights law; international human rights law; constitutional human rights; comparative legal pedagogy |
| References | Authored books 1. Dederer Hans-Georg, Schweitzer Michael, Staatsrecht III: Staatsrecht, Völkerrecht, Europarecht (C F Müller 2024). 2. Degenhart Christoph, Staatsrecht I: Staatsorganisationsrecht. Mit Bezügen zum Europarecht (41. Aufl, C H Beck 2025). 3. Ipsen Jörn, Staatsrecht I (Staatsorganisationsrecht) (32. Aufl, Vahlen 2020). 4. Maurer H, Schwarz K-A, Staatsrecht I: Grundlagen, Verfassungsorgane, Staatsfunktionen (7., grundlegend überarbeitete und ergänzte Auflage, Verlag C.H. Beck 2023). 5. Pieroth B, Schlink B, Kingreen T, Poscher R, Grundrechte. Staatsrecht II (40. Aufl, C F Müller 2024). 6. Fedorenko V, Konstytutsiine pravo Ukrainy: pidruch. (Lira-K 2016) (in Ukrainian). 7. Pankevych O, Derzhavne pravo zarubizhnykh derzhav: pidruchnyk (Lvivskyi derzhavnyi universytet vnutrishnikh sprav 2018) (in Ukrainian). 8. Shapoval V, Konstytutsiine pravo zarubizhnykh krain. Akademichnyi kurs: pidruchnyk (13-te vyd., vyprav. ta dopov, Yurinkom Inter 2023) (in Ukrainian). Edited books 9. Hegel G W F, Werke in zwanzig Bänden vol 5. Wissenschaft der Logik I (Eva Moldenhauer, Karl Markus Michel (eds), Suhrkamp Verlag 1986). 10. Afanasieva M, Yezerov A (red), Konstytutsiine pravo Ukrainy: prahmatychnyi kurs: navch. posib. (Iurydychna literatura 2017) (in Ukrainian). 11. Bila knyha z reformuvannia ukrainskoi yurydychnoi osvity (Weissbuch zur Reform der ukrainischen juristischen Ausbildung): za materialamy mizhnarodnoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii “Ievropeizatsiia ukrainskoi yurydychnoi osvity: nimetsko-ukrainskyi dosvid” (R Melnyk, O Shablii i B Shloer (uporiad), Naukovyi park Kyivskoho natsionalnoho universytetu imeni Tarasa Shevchenka 2015) (in Ukrainian). 12. Koziubra M (zah red), Konstytutsiine pravo: pidruchnyk (Vaite 2021) (in Ukrainian). 13. Slinko T (red), Konstytutsiine pravo Ukrainy: pidruchnyk (Pravo 2020) (in Ukrainian). 14. Terletskyi D (red), Konstytutsiine pravo: navch. posibnyk (Feniks 2023) (in Ukrainian). Journal articles 15. Martin F F, Tushnet M, ‘Integrating International Human Rights and Comparative Constitutional Law into the U.S. Constitutional Law Course’ [1999] 93 Proceedings of the Annual Meeting (American Society of International Law) 357. 16. Mubangizi J C, McQuoid-Mason D J, ‘Teaching Human Rights in Commonwealth University Law Schools: Approaches and Challenges, with Passing References to Some South African Experiences’ [2020] 41(1) Obiter 106–121. 17. Seredynko A, ‘Suchasni modeli yurydychnoi osvity (na prykladi SShA ta Nimechchyny)’ [2022] 10 Yurydychnyi naukovyi elektronnyi zhurnal 43 https://doi.org/10.32782/2524- 0374/2022-10/8 (in Ukrainian). Theses 18. Baranova Yu, ‘Metodolohichni pravyla porivnialno-pravovykh doslidzhen’ (dys kand yuryd nauk, 2015) (in Ukrainian). Conference papers 19. Orhanizatsiia yurydychnoi nauky ta osvity v Ukraini y sviti: istorychnyi dosvid, suchasnyi stan ta maibutni perspektyvy. Do 85-littia vid dnia narodzhennia ta 55-littia vid pochatku naukovoi diialnosti akademika NAN Ukrainy Yu. S. Shemshuchenka: materialy KhI Mizhnar. nauk.- praktych. konf. (Kyiv, 22 hrud. 2020 r.): zb. nauk. pr. (N M Parkhomenko ta in (red), Instytut derzhavy i prava imeni V M Koretskoho NAN Ukrainy 2021) (in Ukrainian). Websites 20. Guidelines and Sample Curricula on Human Rights Law (Norwegian Centre for Human Rights 2022) (accessed 20.06.2026). 21. Svenson D R, ‘Komentari ta rekomendatsii shchodo proektu standartu osvitno-profesiinoi prohramy pershoho (bakalavrskoho) rivnia vyshchoi osvity zi spetsialnosti “Pravo” v Ukraini’ (Proiekt USAID “Spravedlyve pravosuddia” 2015) 13 (accessed 20.06.2026) (in Ukrainian). |
| Electronic version | Download |